Can You Sue an HOA for Negligence After a Slip and Fall, Trip and Fall or Other Injury in Florida?
October 19, 2023 – Michael S. Herman, Jr., Esq.
Condominium and homeowners associations offer a unique blend of community living and convenience. With shared spaces and amenities, it’s like having extended home comforts just outside your front door. Considering this appeal, it’s not surprising that out of 8.9 million homes in Florida, a significant 3.9 million — or about 45% — are part of homeowners’ associations (HOAs).
But what happens when a seemingly safe hallway becomes the scene of a slip and fall? Or when you experience a trip and fall in a poorly maintained parking lot, the most common place for such incidents? Or when a neglected amenity leads to a serious injury? Suddenly, you’re faced with pain, medical bills, and pressing questions: “Is the HOA at fault? Can I sue an HOA for negligence?” or “Is the condominium association at fault? Can I sue the condominium association for negligence?”
The short answer is “yes.” Continue reading to learn the details.
Understanding the Role and Responsibilities of HOAs and Condo Associations
HOAs and Condo Associations are essential in community living. Though the terms are sometimes used interchangeably, they serve different housing types. HOAs usually manage single-family homes or townhomes, whereas Condo Associations handle condominium complexes.
For the purposes of this blog, “HOA” refers to the governing body responsible for the maintenance and safety of common areas within a condo community in Florida. The HOA is legally bound to keep common areas safe, addressing hazards like broken tiles or inadequate lighting.
If an HOA fails to uphold these responsibilities and an injury occurs as a result, it could be held accountable for negligence. However, proving negligence if you’ve been injured due to a slip or trip and fall or some other hazard is not always easy and requires the help of an experienced slip trip and fall lawyer.
Potential Negligence Scenarios in HOA-Managed Properties
Condominium Associations and HOAs have a duty to maintain their common areas in a reasonably safe condition for residents and guests, and a duty to warn residents and guests of hazardous conditions in common areas. Simply put, if a danger or hazard that poses risk of injury exists, they should take steps to remedy or eliminate the danger or hazard.
When they breach these duties, they may be guilty of negligence. Since an HOA is tasked with maintaining safety standards for its residents and their guests, negligence can sometimes lead to hazards that result in injuries. Below are some scenarios where an HOA’s oversight might give rise to accidents and injuries:
- Swimming Pool Incidents: Pools without appropriate fencing or gates may allow for unauthorized and unsupervised access, potentially leading to drownings or injuries. Additionally, pools with imbalanced chemicals can result in skin irritations or respiratory issues for swimmers.
- Slip and Fall Hazards: Lobbies or pool decks that regularly experience water spillage, without proper drainage or timely cleanup, can become slip and fall hazards. The absence of cautionary signage further increases the risk.
- Maintenance Equipment: Leaving tools, machinery, or equipment unattended in hallways, gardens, or other common areas not only disrupts the aesthetics but can also pose significant tripping hazards, especially if they’re obscured from plain view.
- Cracked/Raised Sidewalks: Neglected sidewalks can crack and raise, often due to the roots of nearby trees in older communities. These cracked and raised sidewalks pose a serious trip hazard to community residents and visitors who use the sidewalks. Oftentimes, condominiums and homeowners associations will try to cheaply fill cracks and grind raised walking surfaces, rather than replace them when needed.
- Stairways: Neglected stairways can lead to serious personal injuries; cracking and rusted steps, stairways without proper slip resistance, poorly designed stairways that do not meet applicable codes and ordinances, and broken railings are just a few examples of potential injury hazards for condominium and HOA residents.
- Playground Injuries: Play areas with outdated, rusty, or broken equipment increase the risk of injuries to children. Lack of regular inspections and maintenance by the HOA can make these areas particularly dangerous.
- Parking Lot Risks: Potholes, uneven surfaces, or the lack of clear demarcation can lead to vehicular accidents. For pedestrians, such conditions, especially when combined with inadequate lighting, increase the risk of falls.
- Elevator Malfunctions: Elevators in multi-story condos that aren’t serviced regularly can malfunction. This could lead to situations where residents are trapped inside or suffer injuries from sudden jolts or stops.
- Poor Lighting: Dimly lit hallways, staircases, or parking areas can not only lead to trip and fall accidents but also pose potential security risks, making residents and visitors susceptible to criminal activities.
These are just a few examples showing that HOAs have a substantial duty in ensuring the safety and well-being of those within their managed properties.
Identifying Responsible Parties
In Florida, an HOA may be held liable for negligence if it fails to exercise ordinary and reasonable care. When determining liability in an HOA negligence case, it’s crucial to ascertain whether the HOA, property management company, or individual homeowners are at fault.
It’s worth noting that in some instances, multiple parties might share responsibility, adding layers of complexity to the legal proceedings. For example, while the HOA might be responsible for the overall maintenance of a shared space, a property management company might be tasked with its day-to-day upkeep. There can also be other third parties involved like maintenance companies and contractors who may have been negligent in causing your injuries.
If an accident occurs due to a broken stair railing that multiple parties knew about but neither addressed, multiple parties could potentially be found negligent.
Given these intricate relationships and the potential for shared liability, a consultation with a Florida personal injury lawyer experienced in Florida premises liability law is essential. Their experience and familiarity with the law can safeguard your rights and ensure your claim is filed effectively and in a timely manner.
Establishing a Legal Claim Against Your HOA for an Injury
To build a solid legal claim against your HOA, you’ll need to show certain key things:
- Duty of Care (The HOA’s Responsibility): First and foremost, you need to identify and establish that the HOA owed you a duty of care. This means demonstrating that the HOA had a specific responsibility to maintain the area where you were injured in a safe condition, and to warn of any hazards.
For instance, if the HOA bylaws or rules mention regular maintenance of common spaces and they’ve overlooked a broken tile or cracked sidewalk, this could be evidence of them neglecting their duties.
- Breach of Duty (The HOA’s Failure): Once you’ve established the duty of care, you must then prove that the HOA breached that duty. This involves showing how the HOA failed to maintain safety standards, warn you of the danger, or timely correct and eliminate hazards.
- Causation (Linking the Injury to the HOA’s Failure): It’s not enough to show that the HOA had a duty and breached it; you must also connect that breach directly to your injury. This might involve gathering compelling evidence like photos, witness accounts, and medical reports to link the HOA’s negligence to your incident.
- Damages (Calculating Your Total Costs): The final element requires you to quantify the damages you suffered as a result of the HOA’s negligence. This encompasses hospital bills, lost wages, and other damages, such as pain and suffering or emotional distress.
An understanding of these elements, backed by compelling evidence and documentation, can significantly bolster your claim. For a more detailed look at injury damages, you may find our blog, “What is Your Injury Case Really Worth?” informative.
Common Injuries After a Slip and Fall or Trip and Fall on HOA and Property
- Neck/Back Injuries: Slip and falls can lead to neck and back injuries, often involving strained muscles or herniated discs. These injuries can cause severe pain, limited mobility, and may require physical therapy or surgery for recovery.
- Fractures: Fractures, such as broken wrists, arms, or legs, are common in slip and fall accidents. They can result from the impact of the fall or attempts to break the fall with an outstretched hand. Fractures may necessitate casts, surgery, or rehabilitation.
- Concussion/Traumatic Brain Injuries (TBIs): A slip and fall can cause head trauma, leading to concussions or more severe traumatic brain injuries. Symptoms may range from headaches and dizziness to memory loss and cognitive impairment. Seeking prompt medical attention is crucial.
- Shoulder Injuries: Shoulder injuries like dislocations, strains, or rotator cuff tears can occur when someone falls and lands on their shoulder. Recovery may involve physical therapy or surgical interventions, depending on the severity of the injury.
- Hip Injuries: Hip fractures or strains are common among older adults in slip and fall incidents. These injuries can be especially debilitating and often require surgery, rehabilitation, and long-term care.
- Foot/Ankle Injuries: Slip and falls can result in sprained ankles, broken feet, or even torn ligaments. Proper diagnosis and treatment are essential for recovery, which may include immobilization, physical therapy, or surgery.
- Knee Injuries: Injuries to the knees, such as ligament tears or dislocations, can occur during a slip and fall. These injuries can lead to pain, instability, and the need for surgical intervention or physical therapy.
- Cuts and Abrasions: Slips and falls can cause cuts, scrapes, and abrasions, which may lead to infections if not properly cleaned and treated. Immediate wound care is essential to prevent complications.
- Sprained Wrists: Landing on outstretched hands during a fall can result in sprained wrists. These injuries can be painful and may require splints, braces, or physical therapy for recovery.
- Facial Injuries: Slip and falls can lead to facial injuries, including cuts, bruises, and broken bones (e.g., nose or jaw fractures). Treatment may involve sutures, splints, or even reconstructive surgery, depending on the severity.
Steps to Take After a Slip and Fall Accident in an HOA Property
Time is of the essence when dealing with injuries on HOA properties. Acting swiftly can strengthen your case and help preserve evidence that might otherwise be lost or overlooked. Here are the steps you should prioritize:
- Medical Attention: Don’t delay in getting medical care. Immediate medical attention not only addresses your health concerns but also establishes a crucial timeline that can later serve as evidence.
- Document Everything: From photographs of the scene, conditions, and any visible injuries, to collecting names and contact information of potential witnesses — thorough documentation can be a game-changer.
- Inform the HOA: Reporting the accident to the HOA or property management company without delay can play a significant role. It establishes a timeline, ensuring the HOA cannot later claim ignorance about the incident. However, you should not give any oral or written statements regarding the incident and should consult with a lawyer before filling out any incident reports or other paperwork.
- Consult a Lawyer: Seeking advice from an experienced attorney can guide your next steps and ensure you’re taking the right actions within the necessary timeframes. They can also advise on critical deadlines and statutes of limitations that may apply.
Delaying any of these steps can complicate matters and potentially weaken your claim. It’s essential to be proactive and vigilant, ensuring your rights are protected from the outset.
We realize that being injured due to HOA negligence can be a frustrating and painful experience. However, you don’t have to suffer in silence or accept the burden of your damages alone. By suing your HOA for negligence and hiring an experienced trip and fall lawyer, you can hold the responsible parties accountable and seek fair compensation for your injuries.
Injured? We Can Help
At Britto & Herman Injury Lawyers, we’re dedicated to serving Florida injury victims in all Florida counties. We’ve spent a combined 25 years defending both condominium and homeowners associations against negligence claims. This unique experience has given us a deep understanding of how insurance companies evaluate and approach these claims.
Now, we’re leveraging that knowledge to fight for victims and ensure you receive just compensation for your injuries – and we are dedicated to Florida injury victims. Moreover, attorney Daniel Britto is a Board Certified Civil Trial Lawyer. Rest assured, with us, you’re not just getting any representation – you’re securing experienced former insurance company lawyers who defended slip trip and fall cases before starting their law firm.
For your convenience, our injury lawyers are available 24/7, and we offer virtual free case evaluations and paperless sign-ups. If you’ve been searching online for a “personal injury lawyer near me,” call us instead at (561) 835-5555(561) 835-5555 and press “0” to speak to the first available lawyer. We can help you if you’ve been injured due to a condominium association or HOA’s negligence.
Britto & Herman Injury Lawyers – The Voice for Florida Injury Victims
For more information on how personal injury lawyers can take your case with $0 down and receive no fee unless we win, read our blog: Do I Have to Pay My Personal Injury Lawyer?
Copyright © 2023. Britto & Herman Injury Lawyers. All rights reserved.
The information in this blog post (“post”) is provided for general informational purposes only and may not reflect the current law in your jurisdiction. No information in this post should be construed as legal advice from the individual author or the law firm, nor is it intended to be a substitute for legal counsel on any subject matter. No reader of this post should act or refrain from acting based on any information included in or accessible through this post without seeking the appropriate legal or other professional advice on the particular facts and circumstances at issue from a lawyer licensed in the recipient’s state, country, or other appropriate licensing jurisdiction.
Britto & Herman Injury Lawyers
Ask a question, describe your situation,
Request a Free Consultation
Your Information Is Safe With Us
We respect your privacy. The information you provide will be used to answer your question or to schedule an appointment if requested.